Thursday, April 20, 2017

Taxpayers Foot $40,000 Bill For "Emergency" Phones In Lousy Locations (PS-The Phones May Not Work, Either)

Tax money paid for this "emergency" phone near the Sheridan Red Line at a cost of $20,000.
Two recently installed emergency call boxes on the far north end of Lakeview came at a steep price for local taxpayers: $20,000. Each.

Even worse than the price tag may be the fact that some residents now want the boxes removed and there are indications that the phones—designed to help victims report police emergencies—don't work reliably.

A CWBChicago investigation has found no public records about the phone project; no records about how the contractor was selected; and no records to shed light on the decision to plant the phones on the northern border of Lakeview instead of near well-known crime centers.

The two phone purchases were made with tax dollars entrusted to Chicago View, formerly known as Central Lakeview Merchants Association, a now-defunct business group that oversaw nearly $800,000 a year in local tax monies called SSA funds.

The tax funds were supposed to be used to spruce up streetscapes, enhance security and boost business on long stretches of local commercial streets: Belmont from Racine to Halsted; Clark from Belmont to Byron; Sheffield from Diversey to Irving Park; and Addison from west of Clark to Reta.

"Safety Programs"

Books and records reviewed by CWBChicago show that Chicago View and local SSA commissioners largely ignored the public's call for more public safety initiatives in recent years.

In 2013, the group spent a total of $2,000 on items it claimed were for "public safety." $1,200 of that tax money was for a T-mobile cell phone, and another $800 was paid to Constant Contact, a company that specializes in email newsletters.
In papers filed with the city, SSA #17 budgeted $2,400 for safety in 2014. It paid for a cell phone.
In 2014, Chicago View budgeted $2,400 of taxpayer funds for "safety programs," but only $1,299 of that was spent. Again, the "safety program" for the year was simply a T-Mobile account labeled "security phone."

And 2015's safety budget was used for the T-Mobile phone until October 25. That's when Chicago View first applied for a city permit to install the emergency call box on Sheridan Road at Dakin.

One month later, Chicago View distributed $9,878.76 to Keyth Security Systems. That would be the first of many payments to Keyth—eventually totaling $40,0056.96 for the two call stations, which are located about one block apart.

Location, Location, Location

If the concept behind the phones was to give crime victims a way to communicate during an emergency, Chicago View could not have selected installation sites farther from neighborhood crime centers.

Year after year, Chicago Police Department statistics show that street crime in Lakeview is centered around Belmont and Sheffield. Secondary hot spots include the 800- to 1000 blocks of West Belmont; and the 3500 block of North Clark Street.

All of those areas were within Chicago View's oversight yet none of them was selected for the 5-figure emergency phone systems.

This heat map, created with Chicago Police Department data, plots reported crime in our area during 2015 and 2016, with red areas having the highest concentration of incidents. The black lines are the streets included in SSA #17 and the numerals 1 and 2 mark the locations where Chicago View chose to install call boxes.
Heat map source: Chicago Data Portal
The Fremont/Irving box is located across from Thorek Hospital
Making site selection more questionable is the fact that the Fremont/Irving Park phone is located about 15 feet south of the intersection where it cannot be seen from many angles. It's also across the street from Thorek Hospital, which would seemingly offer crime victims a reliable place to seek help in the area.

CWBChicago editors reviewed three years of books and records from Chicago View. None of their public meeting agendas or minutes contain any reference to the call box project.

And the group's annual contracts with the city, which required them to disclose contractors who would be paid more than $10,000 in taxpayer funds, never mention Keyth or the phone projects.

Businesses and neighbors who live near the call boxes were apparently not asked about the call box idea. Because some of them are now circulating a petition to have the phones removed.

The bright blue boxes are unsightly and project an image of being in a high crime area, they say.

44th Ward Alderman Tom Tunney stripped SSA oversight from Chicago View in November after cries of poor service and misplaced priorities became too loud for the city to ignore.

"The city wanted to revisit, frankly, how they spend taxpayer money," Tunney aide Chris Jessup told DNAInfo at the time.

Now, the service area is under the stewardship of the Lakeview East Chamber of Commerce.

Cleaning Up

Martino (center) and Lakeview East Chamber Of Commerce workers
Asked about the camera project undertaken by the previous administrators, Lakeview East Chamber of Commerce Executive Director Maureen Martino was candid.

“We don’t have any information why [Chicago View] choose these areas and if there were any public meetings or surveys or stats taken to best determine the locations for these boxes,” Martino said.

Have the phones ever actually been used in an emergency?

"The usage is very minimal," Martino said, “and when tested, there was no response, so the effectiveness of the boxes are not showing favorable.”

Useless Records

The call boxes aren't the only thing not mentioned in the minutes and agendas of SSA #17's public meetings held on Chicago View's watch.

The truth is that those records show almost no detail about anything that was discussed at any of their meetings since 2013.
Chicago View's SSA meeting minutes were routinely sparse and free of detail 

Martino's group is the long-time administrator of a different Lakeview SSA that serves the Broadway commercial strip.

Public records show that her team has routinely published detailed minutes of that SSA's meetings, providing taxpayers and businesses with a transparent look at what's being done with public money.
Lakeview East Chamber's SSA minutes are full of detail about the public's business.
Their September 2016 minutes run 1.5 pages. (Above and below)
As for public safety expenses, the chamber has focused on providing security patrols in its service area during crucial hours, according to books and records furnished by the city.

And private patrols are the backbone of Martino's security plan for the area formerly overseen by Chicago View.

Soliciting public bids for patrol services and awarding a contract were among the first things her group did this year.

Refreshingly, the Chamber of Commerce is focusing its public safety efforts on well-known crime hot spots.

The Belmont corridor will be a focus of its private patrols, and a satellite security office is being established in a storefront at Belmont and Sheffield.

As for the $40,000 call boxes on the north end of her new territory, Martino said the phones "are currently under review.”
----------
Email us. Facebook us. Twitter us.

17 comments:

  1. Money should of been used to hire more real police in Lake View to patrol the neighborhood, how stupid

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ordinary I would've assumed that someone's been paid off to build these things, but wasn't the Chicago View org canned for being entirely incompetent?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent reporting CWB! Thanks for the Daylight exposing mismanagement of these slush funds.
    Follow the money.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great article CWB, original reporting at its finest.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Martino is great. (No, really - not being sarcastic.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I've met her a few times and she is very committed to the safety and prosperity of the Lakeview community.

      Delete
  6. They probably chose those locations because if they put them in the crime hot spots, they'd be stolen or destroyed. What a huge waste of money! Once again, our "leaders" don't have a clue what the area & residents need or want.

    I'm sure the Keyth company who installed these useless, over-priced devices is owned by one of the decision makers (or at least a family or friend of said decision maker) who approved this ridiculous "safety program."

    ReplyDelete
  7. and who put the orignal members in charge and who gave them a budget.......Tom Turkey?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tom Turkey ? LOL I love that name. Yes, you are right on the money. His sticky little cinnamon bun finger prints are all over that budget.

      Delete
  8. What we need is real cameras at those crime hotspots. Those existing camera pods are useless for identifying criminals beyond a description of clothing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Another attempt to Rahm to replace real Police with virtual police, just as useless as his surveillance cameras that nobody monitors.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you read the article, Rahm has nothing to do with this.

      Delete
  10. Fantastic reporting! After a little investigating of our own, we knew this was the case and organized the petition to remove these phones. However, we didn't even realize *how right* we were until this full report. We're ecstatic to now be under the leadership and guidance of Maureen and the Lakeview East Chamber of Commerce. It's onward and upward from here.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Keyth Technologies. That's the real story. Good luck getting it too. Keyth is a tiny privately owned outfit out of Highland Park. ADT? Guess again. This is a local bozo outfit ripe for the machine. My personal bet is that they are side-linked to Chamberlain, which is the race-track syndicate guy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This is what our increased property taxes pay for.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is excellent reporting!
    I have talked with the Lakeview East Chamber of Commerce staff and they are on our side with the crime and its causes. I know some of them use this website to help keep informed.

    Congratulations! the Go fund me has met it target!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Whoa! We learned about the GoFundMe success from you. Thanks for the good news--and to the local businesses and neighbors who contributed. This is such great news!

      Delete